Do you have to read Richard Osman books in order, or can you dive into the literary chaos like a squirrel on espresso?

When it comes to Richard Osman’s books, the question of whether to read them in order is as divisive as pineapple on pizza. Some readers swear by the chronological approach, while others embrace the chaos of jumping into the series wherever they please. Let’s explore the arguments for and against reading Osman’s books in order, and why this debate might just be the literary equivalent of choosing between tea and coffee.

The Case for Reading in Order

1. Character Development: Richard Osman’s Thursday Murder Club series is built around a core group of characters, each with their own quirks, backstories, and evolving relationships. Reading the books in order allows you to witness their growth and transformations over time. For instance, Elizabeth’s sharp wit and Joyce’s endearing optimism become more nuanced as the series progresses.

2. Plot Continuity: While each book has its own self-contained mystery, there are overarching storylines and subtle references that connect the series. Reading out of order might leave you scratching your head at inside jokes or recurring themes, like the ever-present rivalry between the local police and the amateur sleuths.

3. Emotional Investment: Starting from the beginning allows you to build a deeper emotional connection with the characters. By the time you reach the later books, you’ll feel like you’re solving crimes alongside old friends rather than strangers.

4. Author’s Intent: Osman has crafted the series with a clear progression in mind. Reading in order ensures you experience the story as the author intended, with all its twists, turns, and emotional beats in the right sequence.

The Case Against Reading in Order

1. Standalone Mysteries: Each book in the Thursday Murder Club series features a unique mystery that can be enjoyed on its own. If you’re more interested in the whodunit aspect than the character arcs, you can dive into any book without feeling lost.

2. Flexibility: Life is chaotic, and so is reading. Maybe you picked up the third book at a bookstore because the cover caught your eye. Why not start there? You can always circle back to the earlier books later. After all, reading should be fun, not a rigid chore.

3. Discovering Easter Eggs: Reading out of order can be like solving a puzzle in reverse. When you eventually go back to the earlier books, you’ll spot foreshadowing and Easter eggs that you might have missed if you’d read them in sequence.

4. No Spoilers, No Problem: Unlike some series where spoilers are a major concern, Osman’s books are designed to be accessible. Even if you know how one mystery ends, the journey is what makes it worthwhile.

The Middle Ground: A Hybrid Approach

For those who can’t decide, there’s a third option: a hybrid approach. Start with the first book to get a feel for the characters and setting, then feel free to jump around based on your mood or availability. This way, you get the best of both worlds—structure and spontaneity.

Why This Debate Matters

The question of whether to read Richard Osman’s books in order isn’t just about the series itself; it’s a reflection of how we approach storytelling in general. Do we value structure and continuity, or do we prioritize flexibility and individual enjoyment? The answer might say more about us as readers than about the books themselves.

Related Q&A

Q: Can I start with The Man Who Died Twice if I haven’t read The Thursday Murder Club?
A: Absolutely! While reading the first book provides context, The Man Who Died Twice stands on its own as a compelling mystery.

Q: Will I miss out on important details if I read the books out of order?
A: Not significantly. Each book is designed to be accessible, though you might miss some character nuances and recurring jokes.

Q: How many books are in the Thursday Murder Club series?
A: As of now, there are four books, with more expected in the future. The series shows no signs of slowing down!

Q: Are Richard Osman’s books suitable for all ages?
A: While the books are generally lighthearted, they do deal with mature themes like crime and aging, making them better suited for older teens and adults.

Q: What makes Richard Osman’s writing style unique?
A: Osman blends humor, heart, and clever plotting, creating stories that are both entertaining and emotionally resonant. His background in comedy shines through in his witty dialogue and quirky characters.